LLMs Show a Distinct 'Ground-Up' Style in Mathematical Proofs
Researchers asked three large language models to independently reprove all 465 propositions of Euclid's Elements and compared their citation choices with human proofs using Jaccard similarity and network analysis. AI-generated proofs were highly consistent across runs, with mean pairwise Jaccard similarity around 0.68 among AI runs versus about 0.37 between AI and human proofs. About 40% of AI citations pointed to foundational elements such as definitions, common notions and postulates, compared with 13% in human proofs, and AI cited more distant theorem results. The authors describe this stable pattern as 'building from the ground up' and connect it to interpretability concerns around AI-generated proofs.
It provides concrete evidence that LLM-generated mathematical proofs follow a reproducible citation style distinct from human proofs, with direct implications for proof interpretability.
Comments & Questions (0)
No comments yet
Be the first to comment!