Back to AI News
arxiv

LLM-Generated World Models Can Be Mechanically Valid but Structurally Wrong

A new arXiv study evaluates whether five LLMs can generate formal world models for neuro-symbolic reasoning as partially observable stochastic games. It introduces a 44-scenario benchmark and analyzes 410 first-pass generations across mechanical validity, reference-relative structural agreement, and semantic criteria. In the game track, 134 of 135 models passed a strict mechanical audit, but mean structural F1 was only 0.366 and just 28 of 134 exactly matched the authored reference. Naming a country in the cultural track changed structural representations for most LLMs while producing only small semantic-score changes.

AI Brief

It shows that executable LLM-generated world models may still diverge structurally from intended decision problems, a key limitation for neuro-symbolic planning and verification.

arXiv:2611.14419v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Formal world models can support planning, verification, and safety reasoning, but constructing them from open-ended natural-language situations is difficult, particularly in multi-agent settings where several formalizations may be plausible. We study whether five LLMs can generate such world models as partially observable stochastic games and whether mechanical validity is sufficient to establish that the resulting model faithfully represents the intended decision problem. We introduce a benchmark of 44 scenarios spanning game, situational, and cultural settings and evaluate generated world models along three dimensions: mechanical validity, reference-relative structural agreement, and semantic criteria. Across three empirical tracks, we analyze 410 first-pass generations. In the reference-backed game track, 134/135 generated world models pass a strict mechanical audit, yet mean permutation-invariant structural F1 is only 0.366, with just 28/134 mechanically valid models exactly matching the authored reference. In the cultural track, explicitly naming the country changes the generated structural representation for most LLMs while producing only small changes in automated semantic scores. These results show that executability is a necessary but insufficient criterion for LLM-generated world models: models that are mechanically valid can still differ substantially in the structure used by downstream neuro-symbolic reasoning and planning.
Be the first to rate this article.

Comments & Questions (0)

Captcha
Please be respectful — let's keep the conversation friendly.

No comments yet

Be the first to comment!